Forensic Audiology by Robert and Krista Traynor sets out to guide audiologists through their role as expert witnesses, with a clear focus on legal processes. However, the content is heavily weighted towards the US judicial system, detailing American courtroom structures, legal terminology and procedures for examining and challenging expert witnesses.
For UK-based audiologists, this US-centric approach limits the book’s practical usefulness. While the general principles around giving expert evidence – such as remaining within one’s scope of expertise and understanding how testimony may be challenged – are broadly relevant, the legal specifics do not translate well to the UK context.
We had hoped the book might also address the clinical side of forensic audiology, such as guidance on testing protocols or how to evaluate patient test results objectively in a legal context. Unfortunately, this area is not covered.
At an RRP of around £90, readers may expect more clinical content or wider international relevance. The book is informative in parts and appears up to date, particularly regarding expert witness conduct and legal expectations in the US. However, its value for money is questionable for UK clinicians.
The target audience appears to be audiologists new to forensic work, especially those operating in the US. For that group, the book likely meets its aim. For international readers, especially those in the UK, it falls short of being a comprehensive or practical guide.
A niche but clearly written book that may suit US-based audiologists beginning forensic work.
